Developer Update - 5 November 2026

We’ve now added two new addendums to the Public Instance Ownership question, I hope it helps!

TL;DR
The moderation abilities given to the original instance owner DO NOT transfer to other users in an instance when the original instance owner leaves.

We’re going to be closely monitoring how people react to the change when Public Instance Ownership rolls out, and we’re willing to revert this if it seems to be a net negative.

5 Likes

*an instance ban ends after 60 minutes, so if they just wait an hour they can rejoin the same instance

I personally take issue with “Conditions to Vote Kick not met” because I’ve met some very smug people that know how to force this error to occur and have made themselves immune to the vote kick feature. I think that needs to be overhauled first and foremost.

What if having a person blocked affected Vote Kick polling in some way? So if somebody is well known to be problematic, and many people in that instance have them blocked, it becomes easier for them to get removed?

What if a user’s trust rank and/or account standing affected Vote Kick Polling in some way?

Let’s say you have an instance with a troublemaker, you, and 3 other people. the 3 people have the troublemaker blocked already, and they’re harassing you so you vote kick them. To my best knowledge, in the current system, it would say conditions to start a vote are not met, when I believe it should see that all other users have them blocked and the vote should pass instantly. I wouldn’t have blocked users count as a yes vote but I wouldn’t have them count as abstain either, it’d have to be weighted somehow that I haven’t figured out on the spot. Complex voting is hard but I’m certain a good compromise is very doable.

If we can come to some consensus about how we would want this to be implemented, it would be wise to create and subsequently link a Canny post for it.

2 Likes

Video Player locks would absolutely benefit from this

postal2-sign-my-petition-1985754634

Motion Vectors are those exact “Chicken and egg” issues

VRC might have to do the Halo MCC solution and just make it where the Renderer changes based on the world you’re in

1 Like

If it’s a net negative, are you actually going to remove it?

Or will VRChat say you will, wait until the largest supermajority I’ve ever seen in my life agree on it, and then not do it?

The last time you said you’d make a change on community reaction, you proved you were aware of that community reaction and then refused to take the promised action, so why should I trust you now?

2 Likes

World and instances are different things. World creators should not have the power, or responsibility, to moderate users in an instance just because they uploaded the world. If you want to have such control over what happens in your world, consider making your world private or consider supporting a feature where authors can specify a particular vrchat group as the only group allowed to open an instance of their world.

edited because i couldnt figure out how to quote a post

4 Likes

I personally believe that UGC content shouldn’t just be Private or Public, that there should be an Unlisted option and a Whitelisted option.

Unlisted wouldn’t appear in search or on a user’s profile, but would otherwise be public. This is great for maintaining event variants or historical variants of worlds without cluttering your profile, and could still be favorited and set as a homeworld and what have you. This would also add a native feature that avatar search worlds could detect for blacklisting.

Whitelisted would only be available for a select set of users, either selected individually or as a group role. Users subject to the whitelist would be allowed to search for favorite, see in history, and do other actions private content doesn’t allow.

Private worlds would actually be private. When migrating to this new system, all existing private worlds would be modified to be unlisted to maintain closest behavi This would allow users to favor it and make previously private worlds their home world, but a world could be changed to private via the website, so it’s not the worst thing.

If I get enough :heart:s i’ll find or make a Canny post for this

4 Likes

I think the current “Private” for worlds sucks at both being private and unlisted.

It’s neither private or accessible. People can still make any non-public instance they want at any time.

If people want to keep variants of their world, it either clutters their profile or people can’t make public instances of them, with no in between.

For a long time I kept unfinished worlds private but accessible via portal. I gave up on that because people couldn’t favorite them or make them homeworlds, so I gave up and made them fully public.

1 Like

“and we’ll be closely monitoring how the community responds to the change when this rolls out.”

The same way you guys (do not) monitor Group Public instances? What a relief!!

Also: only a REAAAAALLY small percentage of victims of bad actors with power will be willing to report and be here complaining, so what the hell is VRChat expecting? I have tons of friends who were also victims but don’t even know what to do or don’t have time to take the fight.

Even with the paywall of VRC+ there is already too many people abusing mod tools… Again: what is VRChat expecting? This is just bad, there is no positive point. If VRChat monitoring on power abuse was real, this could work. BUT IT ISN’T!

I must speak for the Brazilian community: THERE IS ALMOST NO HEALTHY GROUP HERE! All of them have a history of abusing power, and the Brazilian community is small, frequenting only two specific worlds. This is something i have been reporting to VRChat for years and nothing has been done.

4 Likes

This might be something you guys are already doing, but Id love to have a Multi group instence. This would be fantastic for events that involve more than one group. Also, all community leaders involved and their staff would have mod privileges over the instance. Any ways I know this is not the right place for recommendations, but I just wanted to pop out the idea =)

4 Likes

Sounds like something worth making a post for on the Canny. Please share if you do, I’d be happy to upvote it

1 Like

The world creator shouldn’t need to moderate their own world, yeah. But vrchat doesn’t have roblox level mic recording and moderation yet so someone has to pick up where they fail.

It’s really hard getting multiple reports about horrible things happening in your world, only to tell them that there’s nothing we can do.

Worlds are allowed to have rules, worlds can enforce those rules. Worlds should be able to actually ban people who ruin the community.

It’s less of controlling what happens, but making sure the community that uses the world isn’t tarnished by malicious people. Any public instance with harmful things and people directly harms the world itself. In a group or group+, do whatever you want, random people can’t join that

2 Likes

I get the distinction, and I agree creators shouldn’t be forced to moderate. Keeping group instances safe should be up to the group’s owners and moderators. That’s why I’m asking for this to be optional. Some creators just want to upload a world and leave it at that, and that’s fine. But some of us have worlds where minors make up a large part of the player base, and we want to keep those spaces safe.

Right now, the same bad actors keep coming back to my worlds or hide in group instances we’ve been banned from, so we can’t moderate them at all. And when something happens, people still bring it to the creator. This isn’t just a me issue either, this is an issue for a lot of other creators I know who run social worlds.

Making the world private or limiting it to one group defeats the point of a public world. People should be able to enjoy it and build their own small communities in it. I’d just like the option to keep repeat offenders out of those public spaces, so our communities and the people in them stay safe.

5 Likes

I maintain the world for a group that’s had similar issues before, where they’re being held responsible for individual bad actors in regular public instances. What is the world owner supposed to do, login and kick the same person once per hour forever? That’s what the community is expecting right now.

I had to personally pressure back against an entire community to not force me to implement a TOS-violating Admin ban panel, especially because the perpetrators were making alt accounts constantly and on top of violating the TOS blatantly with a blacklist script, we’d have to constantly update the list with suspected alt accounts. Not happening.

As a sidenote, the TOS currently doesn’t mention the Creator Guidelines anywhere? Not even in the list of other documents you are subject to. That needs to be fixed otherwise the Creator Guidelines are not enforceable

2 Likes

About public instances ownership: If VRChat wants to keep this feature anyways, at least make it optional, hide the option and make it off by default (and not persistent). Do not let anyone find it easily. It’ll be the same as creating a friends+ instance, but public.

1 Like

Friends++ lol

1 Like

I’m in favor of the unlisted world proposal, as some worlds are kept on “private” to get people to demo/test them but still have some users being able to access them if they’re doing some sort of patreon thing.

1 Like

I don’t believe you.

3 Likes

Private playtests could be handled with Whitelist, and so could Patreon stuff.

If Whitelist was driven by a role in a group, they could integrate it into their shiny ‘Creator Economy’ they like so much, essentially for free. It would get backlash of course, but I’ve already seen Patreon Only worlds that simply don’t let you leave spawn, so it wouldn’t be anything new it would just more supported. If anything, making the world not appear in profiles/search results to those who can’t access it would make it less deceptive.

1 Like

You guys are insufferable.
They already said this in the very first post about the AI issue and its the fact tag monitoring is NOT a scalable solution. They do not have the team or resources to monitor that many projects at the required depth to determine AI usage.

The reason they went with likes and dislikes was because it allows the community to be a free source of moderation.

All you guys have to do is read the post…

4 Likes